Service · 29 CFR part 1607

Selection Assessment and Validation Under the Uniform Guidelines

We build and validate selection procedures (tests, structured interviews, rating scales, technical assessments) so they meet the Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures: a job analysis first, validity evidence that fits the procedure, adverse-impact monitoring under the four-fifths rule, and the documentation section 1607.15 asks for.

What the Rules Require

  • The Uniform Guidelines (29 CFR part 1607) apply to federal agencies as employers. Where a selection procedure has adverse impact, the agency must have validity evidence or use an alternative with less impact (1607.3).
  • Section 1607.14 sets the technical standards for content, criterion and construct validity; 1607.15 lists what the documentation must contain.
  • 5 CFR 300.103 requires that federal employment practices rest on a job analysis and be relevant to performance in the job.

Our Method

  1. Job analysis: tasks and competencies rated by subject matter experts, linked to the assessment plan.
  2. Assessment design: structured interviews, work samples, situational judgment or knowledge tests chosen for the competencies, not by habit.
  3. Validity evidence: content linkage ratings, or a criterion study where samples allow, reported against 1607.14.
  4. Adverse impact: selection rates by group, the four-fifths ratio, and statistical significance, with alternatives considered.
  5. Documentation: a technical report organized to 1607.15, written so a reviewer can follow every number.

Sample Deliverable

Every study ends in a technical report. A redacted outline and one of its tables:

  • 1. Purpose and scope
  • 2. Job analysis method and results
  • 3. Assessment development
  • 4. Validity evidence (1607.14)
  • 5. Adverse impact and alternatives considered (1607.4, 1607.3)
  • 6. Cut scores and use
  • 7. Documentation index (1607.15)
Content linkage summary. SAMPLE: fictional data, not from any agency or client.
CompetencyAssessmentSMEs rating essentialMean linkage (1-5)
Analytical reasoningWork sample11 of 124.6
Written communicationWriting exercise12 of 124.8
Customer serviceStructured interview10 of 124.2

Work With Us

Need an I-O psychology subcontractor for your next human-capital bid? Send the vehicle and what you need. No call required.

Send a teaming request Federal capabilities

Related

Free tools and research

Questions

Do the Uniform Guidelines apply to federal agencies?

Yes. 29 CFR part 1607 covers federal agencies as employers alongside private employers, and 5 CFR part 300 adds federal job analysis requirements.

What kind of validity evidence do you use?

Whatever fits the procedure and the sample: content validity for job knowledge and work samples, criterion studies where enough incumbents and performance data exist, documented to section 1607.14.

Can you work as a subcontractor?

Yes. Most federal assessment work reaches us through primes; see the teaming partners page to send a request without a call.