Use interview scorecards
Create a scorecard per candidate from the role's hiring kit, rate each answer against its anchors on your own, then compare scores and discuss the big disagreements.
Transcript (1:36 video, captions in English)
- How to: use interview scorecards
- WHAT IT'S FOR: The same questions for every candidate, each with anchors for a 1, a 3 and a 5
- What you need first. A role with a hiring kit. Editors create scorecards. Any member can rate
- STEP 1: In New scorecard, choose Role and Candidate. Roles with a published interview guide are listed first
- STEP 2: Check the questions and anchors. Under What a 1, 3 and 5 answer looks like
- STEP 3: Pick Your rating for each question. Open the anchors for each; other ratings stay hidden
- STEP 4: Write your notes, then Submit my ratings. Evidence you heard, not impressions
- STEP 5: Read the Combined score. A spread of 2 or more is marked Discuss
- STEP 6: Start discussion and lock ratings. Needs at least two submitted ratings
- THE SCIENCE: Rate alone first, then compare. Seeing a colleague's score pulls yours toward it
- Summary. One scorecard per candidate. Rate alone, then submit. Discuss the flagged questions
- Full guide: blisspointanalytics.com/help/interview-scorecards
A scorecard holds one candidate's structured interview: the same questions for every candidate, each with a description of what a 1, a 3 and a 5 answer sounds like.
What you need first
- A role in Job architecture with a hiring kit. The scorecard's questions and anchors come from the kit, so run a job analysis or write the kit's questions first.
- Editors, admins and owners create scorecards and start the discussion. Any member of the company, viewers included, can rate.
Steps
- Open Hiring tools. Under 2. Interview scorecards, in New scorecard, choose the Role, type the Candidate's name or a reference, and select Create scorecard.
- If you need to, select Edit questions and anchors, change them and select Save questions. Questions can only be changed before anyone rates.
- Each interviewer opens the scorecard, picks Your rating for each question, writes Your notes (evidence you heard, not impressions) and selects Save draft or Submit my ratings.
- After submitting, each interviewer sees the Panel's ratings and the Combined score.
- When at least two have submitted, an editor selects Start discussion and lock ratings, and the panel talks through the questions marked Discuss.
Who can see what
- Until you submit, only you see your ratings. Other interviewers' ratings appear only after you submit yours.
- Starting the discussion locks every rating, so the record shows what each person thought on their own.
The science in plain words
- BARS stands for behaviorally anchored rating scale: each number is tied to a description of an answer, so two interviewers hearing the same answer are more likely to give the same score. Use 2 and 4 for answers between two anchors.
- Rating on your own first matters: seeing a colleague's score pulls yours toward it. Independent ratings combined afterwards are more reliable than a group agreeing on one score.
- The spread is the highest rating minus the lowest. A spread of 2 or more on a question is flagged for discussion.
Common questions
- There's no role to choose. Add one in Job architecture first.
- Can I change my rating after submitting? No; that keeps the record honest.
- Check your outcomes for adverse impact with the adverse-impact checker. Not legal advice.