Hiring fairness, answered

How do I check a hiring step against the four-fifths rule?

Who is this for?

The short answer

Work out each group's selection rate (people selected divided by people who applied), then divide each rate by the highest group's rate. Under the Uniform Guidelines (29 CFR 1607.4(D)), a ratio below four-fifths (0.80) is generally regarded as evidence of adverse impact. It is a rule of thumb, not proof of discrimination, and passing it isn't proof there is none.

The calculation, step by step

1. Pick one step of the process, such as a résumé screen or an assessment, and count, for each group, how many people went through that step and how many passed it.

2. Divide passed by total for each group. That is the group's selection rate.

3. Find the highest selection rate. Divide every group's rate by it. The result is the impact ratio; the highest group's ratio is 1.00.

4. Flag any group with an impact ratio below 0.80.

The free four-fifths rule calculator does this arithmetic in your browser; nothing you type is sent to a server.

What the result does and doesn't tell you

The Guidelines say the four-fifths rule is a practical way to spot differences worth looking at. The same section notes that smaller differences can still matter, and that differences may not count when the numbers are too small to be meaningful. With small groups, one or two people can swing a ratio, so treat small samples with caution and look at more data or a statistical test.

A ratio below 0.80 is a reason to look closer: at the job-relatedness of the step, at alternatives with less adverse impact, and at whether the data is right. It isn't a legal finding.

Questions

Is the four-fifths rule the law?
It comes from the Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures, 29 CFR 1607.4(D), which describe it as a rule of thumb that is generally regarded as evidence of adverse impact. It isn't a definitive legal test.
Which group do I compare against?
The group with the highest selection rate. Every other group's rate is divided by that one.
Is this the same calculation as a Local Law 144 bias audit?
Related, not identical. A Local Law 144 audit also calculates impact ratios against the most selected (or highest scoring) category, for sex, race/ethnicity and intersectional categories, with rules for unknown and small categories, and it sets no pass or fail threshold.

Sources

This page is general information, not legal advice. Laws change and depend on facts this page can't know; talk to an employment lawyer about your situation.

Get started online

Prefer to talk first? Book a free 15-minute call

From an I-O psychology consultant. Covers NYC Local Law 144, the EU AI Act and the four-fifths rule.