Hiring fairness, answered
Does NYC Local Law 144 apply to my hiring tool?
Who is this for?
- Employers and agencies hiring for jobs in New York CityYou’ll use it to find out whether your screening or scoring tool needs a yearly bias audit.
- HR and talent leadsYou’ll use it to check whether the notice and audit rules reach the tools you already use.
- Vendors of hiring toolsYou’ll use it to answer customers who ask whether your product is covered.
The short answer
It may, if you use an automated employment decision tool to screen candidates or employees for hiring or promotion in New York City. Under the city's rules, a tool counts when its simplified output (a score, tag, classification or ranking) is relied on alone, weighted more than any other criterion, or used to overrule other factors, including human judgment. If it applies, the tool needs a bias audit by an independent auditor within one year before use, a published summary of results, and notices to candidates.
What the rules count as an automated employment decision tool
The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) rules (6 RCNY 5-300) define when a tool "substantially assists or replaces discretionary decision making": relying solely on a simplified output with no other factors considered; using a simplified output as one of a set of criteria where it is weighted more than any other criterion; or using a simplified output to overrule conclusions from other factors, including human decision-making.
So the question is less about whether a vendor calls a product "AI" and more about how your team uses its output. A score that recruiters glance at alongside several equally weighted factors is a different case from a ranking that decides who gets an interview.
What is required if it applies
DCWP's page says an employer or employment agency may use the tool only if it has been subject to a bias audit within one year of its use, information about the audit is publicly available, and the required notices have been given. DCWP began enforcing the law and its rules on July 5, 2023.
The rules (6 RCNY 5-303) say the employer must publish, on the employment section of its website, the date of the most recent bias audit and a summary of results, including the source and explanation of the data, the number of individuals in an unknown category, and the number of applicants, selection or scoring rates and impact ratios for all categories. Notice to candidates must be given at least 10 business days before the tool is used (6 RCNY 5-304).
How to check your own case
List each tool in your hiring and promotion process, write down what it outputs, and describe how that output is used in the decision. Then compare that description with the three cases in the rules. Where the answer is unclear, a lawyer should make the call, because the definition turns on facts about your process.
The free AI hiring law checker lists the laws that may be worth checking based on a few plain questions, including Local Law 144.
Related
Questions
- Does Local Law 144 apply if a human makes the final decision?
- Not automatically either way. The rules look at how the tool's output is used: relied on alone, weighted more than any other criterion, or used to overrule other factors, including human decision-making. A human making the final call doesn't settle the question by itself.
- When did enforcement start?
- DCWP says it began enforcing the law and its rules on July 5, 2023.
- Does Local Law 144 set a pass or fail threshold?
- No. The audit reports selection or scoring rates and impact ratios; the law and rules don't set a threshold a tool must pass.
Sources
This page is general information, not legal advice. Laws change and depend on facts this page can't know; talk to an employment lawyer about your situation.
Prefer to talk first? Book a free 15-minute call
From an I-O psychology consultant. Covers NYC Local Law 144, the EU AI Act and the four-fifths rule.