How does a pay equity analysis work?

Who is this for?

The short answer

A pay equity analysis groups employees doing comparable work, then uses regression to test whether pay differs by sex or race/ethnicity once documented, legitimate factors such as job, level, location and experience are accounted for. The unexplained gaps that remain are reviewed person by person, and the organization decides what to correct, usually with its lawyer.

The analysis in five steps

  1. Collect the data. Pay (base and other forms of pay), job, level, location, hire date, time in role and the demographic fields, from HRIS and payroll.
  2. Group comparable work. Build groups by job content, not by job title, so people doing similar work are compared with each other.
  3. Choose the legitimate factors. Only factors the organization can document and explain, such as level, location and relevant experience.
  4. Model pay. Regression estimates the pay difference by sex and by race/ethnicity within each group, holding those factors constant, with a test of whether each gap is larger than chance would explain.
  5. Review and remediate. Look at the individuals behind each unexplained gap, confirm whether a documented reason exists, and price the adjustments.

Why job content matters

The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission explains that under the Equal Pay Act, men and women in the same workplace must get equal pay for equal work; the jobs need not be identical but must be substantially equal, and job content, not job titles, decides that. It also notes that Title VII, the ADEA and the ADA prohibit pay discrimination on other protected bases without requiring the jobs to be substantially equal.

That is why the grouping step carries so much weight. This page describes the statistical method; it is not legal advice, and which laws apply to your organization is a question for your lawyer.

Why it often runs through a lawyer

Employers commonly commission the analysis through their lawyer so the findings can be privileged while they decide what to fix. BlissPoint's Pay Equity Analysis works that way: groupings of comparable jobs, regression on the factors you can document, unexplained gaps by group and the people they affect, remediation options and their cost, and a written report to you or your lawyer. Where pay decisions sit among other I-O methods is covered in the ROI of workforce analytics.

Keeping pay fair afterward

One analysis is a snapshot. Keeping pay inside defined ranges prevents new gaps: Organization Viewer's pay range review lists people paid below their role's range and ranges not reviewed in 12 months. For the wider picture of outside help, see what workforce analytics consulting is and BlissPoint's workforce analytics consulting modules, where pay equity sits in Pay and Fairness.

More questions

How is a pay equity analysis different from a raw pay gap?

A raw gap compares average pay across the whole organization. A pay equity analysis compares people doing comparable work, after legitimate factors are accounted for.

What data is needed?

Pay, job, level, location, dates of hire and time in role, and the sex and race/ethnicity fields, for current employees.

Does the analysis make us legally compliant?

Not by itself. It is statistical evidence for your decisions, not legal advice or a promise of any legal outcome.

How often should it be repeated?

Repeat it on a regular cycle and after large pay changes, such as an annual pay review or a reorganization, so new gaps are caught early.

Get started online

Prefer to talk first? Book a free 15-minute call

From an I-O psychology consultant. Covers NYC Local Law 144, the EU AI Act and the four-fifths rule.

Sources

← All questions